Online consults across Pakistan Monday to Saturday, 9 am to 9 pm +92 334 2382368
Menopause

Bone Health After Menopause: Osteoporosis and Vitamin D

Bones lose strength faster after menopause. Here's the risk, the vitamin D picture in Karachi, the tests, and simple steps to protect your bones.

A pair of plain flat sandals on the second step of a tiled home staircase, with a folded cotton shawl over the railing, in soft light, no person shown

Quick answer

Bone loss speeds up after menopause, which raises the risk of osteoporosis and broken bones. Vitamin D deficiency was also common in one Karachi study, which found 57% of 784 women deficient. A bone density scan and a vitamin D blood test show where you stand.

  • Bone density starts to fall when oestrogen drops at menopause, and it can fall faster in the decade after your periods stop.
  • One study found 57% of 784 Karachi women were vitamin D deficient. A Lahore study found 73% of 215 women.
  • Osteoporosis often has no signs until a bone breaks, so a bone density (DEXA) scan is how doctors check.
  • Calcium foods, vitamin D, weight-bearing exercise and fall prevention all help protect bones.
  • Don't start vitamin D or calcium tablets on your own. Too much can harm you, so ask a doctor first.

Why do bones get weaker after menopause?

Bones get weaker after menopause because oestrogen, a hormone that helps keep bone density stable, goes down. The Royal Osteoporosis Society says bone density then starts to fall, and changes can happen faster in the decade after your periods stop.

The National Health Service (NHS) in the UK says osteoporosis is most common in older adults and in women after the menopause. The International Osteoporosis Foundation (IOF) describes it as a disease that makes bones weak and fragile.

The IOF also says one in three women over 50 worldwide will break a bone because of osteoporosis.

Menopause isn't the only risk. The NHS lists these other risk factors:

  • A parent with osteoporosis
  • Taking steroid tablets
  • Smoking and drinking too much alcohol
  • Being underweight or inactive
  • Low calcium or low vitamin D

The Royal Osteoporosis Society adds that if menopause starts before 45, and even more so before 40, your bones lose density for longer. That makes osteoporosis more likely later in life. You can read more about early menopause, and about when menopause usually starts.

What are the signs of osteoporosis?

Osteoporosis often has no signs, and the first sign is frequently a broken bone after a minor fall or injury. Back pain, a curved spine or hunched posture, and becoming shorter can also be signs, says the NHS.

The NHS says these signs can come from small breaks in the bones of your spine. So you can have weak bones for years and not feel anything.

Bone problems are only one part of this stage of life. Our guide to other changes at menopause covers the other symptoms you may notice.

How common is vitamin D deficiency in Karachi women?

Vitamin D deficiency was common in one Karachi study of 784 women. In all, 57% were deficient: 64.7% of women before menopause and 49% of women after menopause.

The study was published in BMC Women's Health in 2021. It measured vitamin D in the women's blood.

Women before menopause were more often deficient than women after it, so low vitamin D isn't only an older woman's problem.

The study linked these things to deficiency:

  • Lower socioeconomic status
  • Being under 35
  • Winter

Women who took vitamin D supplements, or who did vigorous exercise, were less likely to be deficient. This kind of study shows links, not proof of cause.

Not sure if your bones need a check? Message us on WhatsApp at +92 334 2382368 with your age and the date of your last period. You don't need any reports yet.

Haddiyon ke baare mein poochna hai? WhatsApp karein.

Is sunshine enough to get vitamin D in Pakistan?

Not always: a study of 215 women in Lahore found 73% were vitamin D deficient, and the Karachi study found 57%. Living in a sunny country doesn't guarantee you have enough vitamin D.

The Lahore study looked at women of child-bearing age. It found more deficiency in women who spent less than 30 minutes a day in the sun.

Women who couldn't read, who didn't take a multivitamin, or who were tested in January to March were also more often deficient.

The NHS explains that your skin makes vitamin D from direct sunlight when you're outdoors. It lists people who rarely go outdoors, people who cover most of their skin outdoors, and people from South Asian backgrounds as higher risk. The NHS timing of late March to September is for the UK, so it doesn't apply to Karachi.

We haven't found a Pakistani source that gives a safe number of minutes in the sun, so we don't give one. Ask a doctor what suits you.

Which tests check bone health?

A DEXA scan, short for dual energy X-ray absorptiometry, checks how dense and strong your bones are. A doctor may refer you for one if you could have osteoporosis.

The NHS says the scan uses low dose X-rays and is quick and painless. It uses a much lower level of radiation than standard X-rays. Your result is compared with a young, healthy adult.

The NHS says a DEXA scan can be offered to:

  • People over 50 who have a risk of osteoporosis
  • People under 50 who have other risk factors, such as smoking or a previous broken bone

The NHS doesn't recommend the scan in pregnancy, because X-rays can harm an unborn baby.

Vitamin D is checked with a blood test. The Karachi study measured it that way. Ask a doctor if you need one.

An online consult can't do a scan or take blood. If you need one, you go to a hospital or lab in person.

How can I protect my bones after menopause?

Eat calcium-rich foods, get enough vitamin D, do weight-bearing and balance exercise, don't smoke, and make your home safer against falls. These steps come from the NHS and the Royal Osteoporosis Society.

HabitWhat the sources say
Calcium foodsThe NHS lists milk and cheese, okra (bhindi), fish eaten with the bones such as sardines, and foods with added calcium. Dahi is a dairy food too. Spinach (palak) isn't a good source, says the NHS, because your body can't absorb all its calcium.
Vitamin D foodsThe NHS lists oily fish such as salmon, sardines, trout, herring and mackerel, egg yolks, red meat and some fortified foods.
Weight-bearing exerciseThe Royal Osteoporosis Society lists walking, stair climbing, jogging, dancing, tennis and heel drops. It also advises strength exercise, using your own body weight, a band or dumbbells, and balance exercise. Build up slowly.
Smoking and alcoholThe NHS says don't smoke, and don't drink too much alcohol.
Preventing fallsThe NHS suggests shoes with good grip and a non-slip mat in the bath or shower. Balance exercise helps keep you steady.

Check with a doctor or physiotherapist first if you've had many broken bones or spinal fractures, or if you're recovering from a broken bone. The Royal Osteoporosis Society gives that advice.

A dietitian can help you plan meals.

Do vitamin D or calcium supplements help?

They can help if you're low, but a doctor should decide, not this page. The NHS says to take a calcium supplement if your doctor prescribes it, and that your doctor may prescribe vitamin D all year round.

In the Karachi study, women who used vitamin D supplements were less likely to be deficient. In Lahore, taking a multivitamin was also linked with less deficiency.

More isn't better. The NHS warns that too much vitamin D can raise calcium in your blood, which can weaken bones and damage the kidneys and heart.

Too much calcium from supplements can cause stomach pain and diarrhoea.

The NHS gives dose advice for people in the UK. We don't copy any dose here, because the right amount depends on your blood test and your health. Please don't start high-dose tablets on your own.

How is osteoporosis treated?

Osteoporosis is a long-term condition, but treatment can reduce the risk of broken bones. Your doctor will talk through the options, and the best one depends on things like your scan result and your age.

The NHS describes two groups of medicine. Bisphosphonates stop or slow down damage to your bones. Anabolic agents speed up the building of new bone.

The NHS also lists lifestyle steps: calcium and vitamin D, a balanced diet, regular exercise, preventing falls, not smoking and limiting alcohol. We don't name medicines or doses here. A doctor chooses them after your tests.

Can hormone therapy help bones?

Hormone therapy (HRT) can be used to treat osteoporosis in some women, but it isn't right for all women. The Royal Osteoporosis Society says it's usually the most appropriate treatment if you're under 50 and past menopause.

It adds that most experts see HRT as a useful option for women between 50 and 60. A doctor has to weigh the risks and benefits for you. The NHS lists HRT as a way to keep bones strong if it's offered for menopause symptoms.

Hormone therapy can slow bone loss, but it has risks, so read the full picture first in our guide to hormone therapy.

When should I see a doctor about my bones?

See a doctor if back pain doesn't improve after a few weeks, if your spine is curving, or if you're worried about your risk. This is the NHS advice for a non-urgent visit.

Ask about your bones too if you're losing height, if your menopause started before 45, or if you take steroid tablets. The NHS lists steroids as a risk factor, and the Royal Osteoporosis Society links early menopause to weaker bones.

If you've had a recent fall and the pain isn't getting better, see a doctor soon. The NHS calls that urgent.

When is a fall an emergency?

Go to the nearest hospital emergency now, or call Edhi on 115. Do this if you have severe pain after a fall or injury, and don't wait for an online reply. The NHS says this needs emergency care.

For ongoing help with menopause, see our page on menopause care.

Menopause ke baad haddiyan kamzor kyun ho jaati hain? (Roman Urdu mein)

Menopause ke baad oestrogen hormone kam ho jata hai. Yeh hormone haddiyon ki density ko sambhaal kar rakhta hai. Is liye haddiyan kamzor ho sakti hain, aur osteoporosis ka khatra barh jata hai.

  • Aksar koi alamat nahi hoti. Kabhi kabhi chhoti si chot par haddi toot jati hai.
  • Kamar dard jo theek na ho, kad chhota hona ya kamar ka jhukna doctor ko dikhane ki wajah hai.
  • DEXA scan se haddiyon ki density check hoti hai. Vitamin D khoon ke test se check hota hai.
  • Vitamin D ya calcium ki goliyan khud se shuru na karein. Pehle doctor se poochein.

What can an online consult do for bone health?

An online consult can cover your history and symptoms, review your reports, give advice and plan the tests you may need. It can't do a physical exam, a bone scan or a blood test, and it can't handle an emergency.

If you need a scan or a test, you go to a hospital or lab in person. If it's an emergency, go to the nearest hospital emergency now and don't wait for an online reply.

Dr. Ayesha Jawed, MBBS, postgraduate trainee in Obstetrics and Gynaecology (CPSP), gives online consultations for Karachi Gynae. A consult costs Rs 499 for up to 1 hour.

She reviews your reports, and you can share clear photos of them on WhatsApp. She can send a prescription when it's safe to do so online.

You can choose video, a call or WhatsApp on +92 334 2382368, Monday to Saturday, 9 am to 9 pm. You can pay by JazzCash, Easypaisa or bank transfer.

If you want to talk about your bones and menopause, book an online consult.

Questions women ask

Can osteoporosis be reversed?

The NHS calls osteoporosis a long-term condition and says treatment can reduce the risk of broken bones. It doesn't say the condition can be reversed, so we can't promise that. A doctor can tell you what's realistic for you.

Is vitamin D deficiency common in Pakistani women?

Yes, in the studies we read. A Karachi study of 784 women found 57% were deficient, and a Lahore study of 215 women found 73%. Those numbers come from specific groups of women, so your own result may differ.

How do I know if my bones are weak?

You often can't tell, because osteoporosis usually has no signs until a bone breaks. A doctor can assess your risk and may refer you for a DEXA scan. Back pain that doesn't settle or losing height are reasons to ask.

Is a bone density scan safe?

The NHS says a DEXA scan uses a much lower level of radiation than standard X-rays. It's quick and painless. It isn't recommended in pregnancy, so tell the staff if you could be pregnant.

What foods are good for bones after menopause?

The NHS lists dairy foods such as milk and cheese, okra, fish eaten with the bones such as sardines, and foods with added calcium. For vitamin D it lists oily fish, egg yolks and red meat. Spinach isn't a good calcium source.

Can you build bone density?

Exercise and food help keep bones strong. The NHS also says some medicines speed up the building of new bone. A doctor decides if you need one, based on your scan and health.

Vitamin D ki kami ka test kab karwana chahiye?

Humein koi source nahi mila jo test ka waqt batata ho, is liye hum koi muddat nahi dete. Karachi ki study mein vitamin D khoon ke test se napa gaya tha. Doctor se poochein ke aap ko test chahiye ya nahi.

Kya dhoop mein baithna kaafi hai?

Hamesha nahi. Lahore ki study mein 73% aur Karachi ki study mein 57% aurtein vitamin D ki kami mein thin. Kitni dhoop theek hai, iska koi Pakistani source humein nahi mila. Doctor se poochein.

Kya doodh aur daal se calcium poora ho jata hai?

NHS ke mutabiq calcium doodh, cheese, bhindi, kaante ke saath sardine jaisi machhli aur calcium wali cheezon mein hota hai. Palak ka calcium jism poora jazb nahi karta. Daal ka source humein nahi mila. Dietitian se poochein.

Online consult, Rs 499

Talk to a lady doctor today

Online consult with Dr. Ayesha Jawed: up to 1 hour, Monday to Saturday, 9 am to 9 pm.

  • Lady doctor
  • Video, call or WhatsApp
  • Private and from home

In an emergency, go to the nearest hospital or call Edhi 115.

Call WhatsApp

This page is coming soon.